franchising aspects 2010-10-04

Whats Better, Franchising Or Joint Venture?

Every business model has its unique identity, plus and minuses. Same goes for franchising and joint venture, the two models of expansion, both of which have their flaws and flaw-less aspects. However, franchising definitely scores over joint venture, as i

By Sub Editor
Whats Better, Franchising Or Joint Venture?

Franchising has taken giant leaps with most of the successful business players adopting the franchising business route to expand their business nationally as well as internationally. At the same time, the trend of venturing into a new country or city by joining hands with another company, i.e. through a joint venture, is also not alien. When we compared the two models, we found that franchising was way ahead when it came to expansion, for the reasons given below.

Disadvantages of joint venture

There are substantial disadvantages to a joint venture operation, which are not unique to franchise concepts and relate to such matters as: who has control; what functions are performed by each of the joint venturers; what is to happen should there be a dispute; what will be the dividend policy of the joint venture (one party may be seeking capital appreciation whilst the other may be looking for an income stream) and how will broad/shareholder approval/consent to major decisions be made.

Says Major KV Rajan, Executive Director, Amoha Education (P) Ltd (Vita), “Joint venture model can be adopted in manufacturing businesses but in education, retail outlets, etc, franchising is the best way to expand business. The franchisees know the local details of any location and can be taught the franchisor’s way of doing business. This cannot be shared in joint ventures.”

Says Sam Chopra, Director, RE/MAX India, "Franchising offers standard set procedures for all the franchisees which helps in optimising the potential, which is absent in the joint venture model. Moreover in joint ventures, there is always more possibility of fall outs and conflicts. Decisions are delayed due to the inability of the partners to come to a decision regarding every small and big issue. Besides, the model of joint venture depends upon case to case. In certain cases, it can be preferred but franchising is always a preferred model to expand.”

Then there are other drawbacks as listed below.

Lack of control: In a joint venture, both the partners are well-experienced. One partner may consider himself more knowledgeable than the parent company. Therefore, he may run the business his way without taking advice of the owner of the company. On the other hand, a franchisee is obligated to follow the rules by contract and he takes each step in accordance with the franchisor. Says Rajan,“There can be a show of dominance by either member in the partnership, which can give bitter results.”

Hindrance in decision-making: Since both the partners are well experienced, in certain cases, it might lead to unresolved issues of dominance in the business. This may lead to wrong decisions by both the partners.

More disputes: A joint venture model can add to more disputes between the partners. The parent company may not prefer the other partner’s way of conducting the business. The latter may employ relatives and friends, who according to the owner of the business, may not have the necessary qualifications and experience.  This may lead to disputes in the long run.

Problem in defining and tracking profits: The absence of fee structure may lead to a lot of problems. Since both the partners share profits and equities, it may lead to unequal distribution, as sometimes the operating partner may feel that he deserves higher profits than the other partner, who “did not work hard.” Moreover, profit sharing among the partners may also lead to bitterness and problems, which do not crop up in the franchise model.

Main advantage is that a joint venture does enable a foreign franchisor to tap into local knowledge and, perhaps, local funding whilst retaining control or involvement in the operation and taking a larger share of the profits than would be the case in a “pure” master franchise or development agreement. Often franchisors strengthen their position by requiring the joint venture company to enter into a master franchise agreement, and possibly also a trade mark licence, in respect of the trade mark to be used in the franchise business.

Secondly, the joint venture partner is an experienced businessman and therefore, needs less training to run the business. This expertise is rarely found among franchisees, who are mostly novices and need the support of the franchisor.

Going by the above pros and cons, franchising surely has an upper hand over a joint venture.

star franchise india
SUMAN BHATTACHARJEE : 26, Jun 2010 at 12:50 AM
i want to open kiosk franchise in food sector.plz find franchise to open it in tripura state.
Mahesh Mirchandani : 29, Jun 2010 at 04:51 AM
Dear Sir, I live in Coimbatore - South India. Can you send me more details on this business. Thanks and Warm Regards, Mahesh Mirchandani
jay tolani : 30, Jun 2010 at 05:44 PM
send some more info to open franchise all over indian airports
simran : 03, Jul 2010 at 07:03 AM
i want this
RAVI KUMAR GUPTA : 05, Jul 2010 at 09:13 AM
want to have a franchise of this.......need help and information regarding this.....
ganesh : 06, Jul 2010 at 01:19 AM
Please send ur complete details with quote
Mujeeb rahman : 08, Jul 2010 at 02:10 AM
Dear Sir, I would like to open a samll kiosk in Cochin internationl Airport . so pls give the idea for that Thanks Mujeeb
kiran : 08, Jul 2010 at 07:25 AM
Dear Sir, I live in vijayawada - South India. Can you send me more details on this business. Thanks and Warm Regards, kiran kumar
Vipin : 09, Jul 2010 at 01:26 AM
I would like to open a ice cream franchisee in North India kindly send be your expert advice
irshad : 12, Jul 2010 at 01:58 AM
we are interested for ur frenchise plz give details for further process awaiting for ur response regards irshad
CHANDER KALWANI : 12, Jul 2010 at 07:29 AM
I live in varanasi. I want to know how i start the small business in my city and how do you help me to start this business.
Sumit Nahata : 22, Aug 2010 at 01:43 PM
sir i runs a shop of cosmetic and gift items and further want to expand my business with a franchise business with low investment till 3-5 lakhs..... plz help me with your expert advice.......
reema kapoor : 24, Sep 2013 at 02:16 PM
want to open kiosk franchise in food sector in mall send details
s.balaji : 27, Nov 2013 at 10:16 AM
i want to open kiosk franchise in food sector. plz find franchise to open it in tamilnadu state.
Related opportunities
  • Ice Creams & Yogurt Parlors
    Natural Ice creams made using Fresh Milk & Seasonal Fruits..
    Locations looking for expansion Haryana
    Establishment year 2019
    Franchising Launch Date 2019
    Investment size Rs. 10lac - 20lac
    Space required 300
    Franchise Outlets -NA-
    Franchise Type Unit
    Headquater Gurgaon Haryana
  • Quick Service Restaurants
    Chef M&N created a very successful concept in the Middle..
    Locations looking for expansion Haryana
    Establishment year 2017
    Franchising Launch Date 2020
    Investment size Rs. 10lac - 20lac
    Space required 350
    Franchise Outlets -NA-
    Franchise Type Unit
    Headquater Faridabad Haryana
  • Established in 2013, Shawarma Factory is India’s top rated Shawarma..
    Locations looking for expansion Maharashtra
    Establishment year 2013
    Franchising Launch Date 2020
    Investment size Rs. 10lac - 20lac
    Space required 140
    Franchise Outlets -NA-
    Franchise Type Unit
    Headquater Mumbai Maharashtra
  • Drinking Water Supply
    About Us: The Procter & Gamble Company (P&G) Manufactures the P&GTM..
    Locations looking for expansion Haryana
    Establishment year 2014
    Franchising Launch Date 2019
    Investment size Rs. 10000 - 50000
    Space required -NA-
    Franchise Outlets -NA-
    Franchise Type -NA-
    Headquater Faridabad Haryana
Insta-Subscribe to
The Franchising World
For hassle free instant subscription, just give your number and email id and our customer care agent will get in touch with you
OR Click here to Subscribe Online
Daily Updates
Submit your email address to receive the latest updates on news & host of opportunities
More Stories

Free Advice - Ask Our Experts

ads ads ads ads